Ed Sheeran row over Macklemore exposes limits of free speech on Gaza

Ed Sheeran’s Loop tour has been left without its announced support acts and touring band after Macklemore was removed for speaking in support of Palestine on stage. <i>(Image: Arnaud Finistre / AFP via Getty Images)</i>
Ed Sheeran’s Loop tour has been left without its announced support acts and touring band after Macklemore was removed for speaking in support of Palestine on stage. (Image: Arnaud Finistre / AFP via Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Ed Sheeran’s Loop tour has been left without its announced support acts and touring band after Macklemore was removed for speaking in support of Palestine on stage.

The row began during two concerts at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, where Macklemore told people in Gaza and the occupied West Bank that they had not been forgotten.

He said “Free Palestine” and performed Hind’s Hall as images of Gaza’s destruction appeared on the stadium screens.

The Israeli-American Council then launched a petition demanding his removal. The tour promoter later said several venues had warned that concerts would not be allowed to go ahead if Macklemore remained on the bill.

Macklemore said Ed Sheeran told him that billionaire Robert Kraft, who owns Gillette Stadium, had rallied other stadium owners and that they collectively issued an ultimatum: remove Macklemore or lose access to their venues.

Robert Kraft confirmed that Macklemore would not be allowed to perform at his stadium, although his statement did not address the claim that he had rallied other owners. The promoter separately confirmed that several venues would not host the tour with Macklemore on the line-up.

That decision prompted Aaron Rowe, Finneas O’Connell, Lukas Graham, and Beoga to withdraw from the remaining dates.

That is the context, but this is not really a story about Macklemore.

As Macklemore said himself, neither man is the victim.

The victims are the Palestinian people killed, injured, displaced, and buried beneath the rubble during the war in Gaza.

Gaza’s Health Ministry reported that 73,789 Palestinians had been killed and 174,798 injured since 7 October 2023 as of 15 September 2026. More people were believed to remain beneath the rubble and in streets that rescue teams could not reach.

More than 20,000 of those reported killed are children. That is the figure that should sit at the centre of this conversation, not the discomfort of celebrities or billionaire stadium owners.

Yet Macklemore's removal raises a wider and deeply uncomfortable question: how free is our speech when a billionaire can reportedly rally other wealthy stadium owners and remove someone's platform for speaking about Gaza and what he has described as genocide?

Robert Kraft is not a politically neutral venue owner. He is worth more than $13 billion and has a long record of support for Israel and Israeli causes. In 2019, Benjamin Netanyahu described him as someone Israel did not have “a more loyal friend” than, while Robert Kraft has said that, after his family, nothing matters more to him than Israel and his Jewish identity.

His Jewish identity is not the issue, and it should not be presented as one. His political advocacy and ability to influence which voices appear on its stage are relevant.

What if Macklemore had used that same platform to warn about AI, climate change, or another humanitarian emergency?

Understandably, those subjects are not treated as being as “controversial” as Palestine, but the principle remains the same.

Who decides what an artist can say? How much power should a small group of billionaires have over political expression? What does freedom of speech mean when access to some of the world’s biggest stages depends on keeping wealthy venue owners comfortable?

Freedom of speech does not guarantee anybody a place on someone else’s tour, but this was not simply a performer being criticised because people disagreed with him. The promoter said venues were prepared to cancel entire concerts if Macklemore remained.

I would say this raises questions about how much influence wealthy venue owners can have over who is given a platform at major events.

It is also important to be honest about what Macklemore actually said.

Addressing Jewish members of the audience, he said: “Criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide, it in no way is criticism of you.

“My message is for peace, love, for all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect, and equality."

He did not call for the extermination of Jewish people. He explicitly separated Jewish people from the actions of the Israeli government and called for freedom, dignity, and equality.

Antisemitism must always be challenged, but criticism of the Israeli government is not hatred towards Jewish people. Opposition to Zionism is not permission for antisemitism.

In my view, when criticism of Israel, opposition to Zionism, or the words "Free Palestine" are automatically conflated with hatred of Jewish people, it can have the effect of shielding the Israeli state from accountability.

Ed Sheeran has said removing Macklemore was the promoter’s decision, not his.

But this is the Loop tour.

There is no Loop tour without Ed Sheeran. The venues are booking him, audiences are paying to see him, and the entire commercial operation is built around his name.

To be clear, nobody is suggesting that Ed Sheeran had the power to control every venue owner or every contract, but there were options available to him that fell somewhere between becoming the loudest pro-Palestine voice in music and simply accepting the decision.

He could have taken the position that artists should have freedom of expression. He could have said he personally supports the right of performers to speak about humanitarian issues. He could have defended Macklemore's right to express a political opinion without necessarily endorsing every word himself.

Instead, he accepted the removal and later suggested he had done so partly because other people relied on the tour for work.

That argument became much harder to sustain when every remaining support act and even members of his own touring band chose to walk away.

The artists with the least power were the ones most willing to take a stand.

He said: “I am not complicit.” But those words do not magically place him outside his own tour.

There was also a noticeable choice in the language he used.

In his statement, Ed Sheeran repeatedly referred to what is happening as a "conflict". That is a term many supporters of Palestine strongly reject because it suggests two roughly equal sides engaged in a dispute.

They point to the vast imbalance in military power, the scale of the destruction in Gaza, and the fact that Israel continues to receive military and political backing from Western allies.

Even the British government has recently announced sanctions against Israeli ministers, marking a significant shift in tone from Westminster.

Describing the situation simply as a "conflict" understates the reality they believe Palestinians are living through.

Which is why I believe people cannot stay 'neutral' anymore.

Ed may not control every venue or contractual decision, but he is hardly a powerless newcomer being told what to do.

If he truly agreed with Macklemore’s message, would he not have used his considerable influence to oppose the decision more forcefully? Would he not have tried to navigate the system around him rather than accepting that the system had spoken?

There is another question that has largely been ignored in the debate.

Ed Sheeran was not blindsided by Macklemore's views on Palestine.

Macklemore has been publicly outspoken on the issue for years. He released Hind's Hall, has repeatedly advocated for Palestinian rights and made similar comments during the first night of the tour in New Jersey. He did not suddenly unveil a secret political position halfway through the tour.

If Ed Sheeran genuinely disagreed with those views, he could have chosen not to invite him onto the tour in the first place.

Instead, the issue only appeared to become a problem once stadium owners, promoters and powerful interests became involved.

That is why it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that this was not really about what Macklemore said, but rather about who objected to him saying it.

Ed Sheeran is one of the most successful musicians of his generation. His tours have grossed hundreds of millions of dollars and his music has generated billions of streams. We can all admit that he doesn't lack financial security and influence.

What is the cost of protecting access to those stadiums? Was protecting ticket sales, venue relationships, and a hugely profitable tour placed ahead of defending an artist's right to speak about Palestinian lives?

In 2022, he performed at the Concert for Ukraine, which raised millions for the Disasters Emergency Committee’s Ukraine appeal.

At the event, he said: “It’s such an important cause and I am so honoured to be here.”

He later explained: “I just wanted to come and do something rather than not doing anything.”

Why, then, is Palestine different?

Many supporters of the Palestinian cause argue that neutrality is still a position when one side holds overwhelming military power and tens of thousands of people have been killed. They argue that silence does not remove politics from the stage and instead allows those already controlling the stage to decide which politics may be heard.

The contrast with Ed's opening act Aaron Rowe is difficult to ignore.

Before withdrawing, the Irish singer had fewer than 200,000 monthly listeners on Spotify. Supporting one of the biggest musicians on the planet in packed stadiums across North America would have been a career-defining opportunity.

Yet et he still walked away and, in doing so, he sacrificed far more than Ed Sheeran ever would have risked by simply defending a fellow artist's right to speak.

Aaron said: “I cannot stand by and allow billionaires to use their position of power to silence the rightful voices of those who speak up against Israeli genocide and who highlight the savage murder of children.

“I would lose all respect for myself to carry on as normal.”

He said he had to remain true to his Irish ancestors who resisted colonisation and fought for the freedom he enjoys today.

Ed Sheeran has also spoken several times about his Irish heritage and drawn heavily on it in his music.

Perhaps he fell asleep during that particular history lesson. Or perhaps Irishness is easier to celebrate when it comes with folk instruments, chart success, and an identity that sells records.

That may sound harsh, but Aaron Rowe had far more professionally to lose. He still decided that staying on the tour would cost him something more important: his self-respect.

Beoga, Finneas O’Connell, and Lukas Graham reached similar conclusions. All withdrew, leaving Ed Sheeran without his announced supporting acts or touring band.

Their decisions show why solidarity matters. One voice can be removed, but it becomes much harder to carry on as normal when several others also refuse.

We are often told to keep politics out of music. People say celebrities owe us nothing beyond entertainment, but music has always been political.

Songs have carried messages about racism, colonialism, poverty, police violence, workers’ rights, climate change, and liberation for generations. Artists have challenged governments, raised money, and helped people understand suffering that might otherwise feel distant.

When hospitals have been attacked, children have been killed and families have been forced repeatedly from their homes, silence from people whose voices reach millions is not empty space.

Today, being apolitical is not enough. When an injustice is happening in full view of the world, I would argue that choosing not to speak can help those with the power to continue it.

This does not mean every celebrity needs to publish a statement about every injustice. But when an artist is removed for saying “Free Palestine”, those with the most power cannot hide indefinitely behind contracts and carefully worded claims of neutrality.

Hind’s Hall was named after five-year-old Hind Rajab, who became trapped in a car with her dead relatives in Gaza City in January 2024.

She spent hours pleading for help during calls with the Palestinian Red Crescent. Her body and those of two paramedics sent to rescue her were recovered 12 days later.

In August 2026, the Israeli military acknowledged for the first time that its soldiers had fired at the family’s vehicle, reversing its previous claim that troops were not in the area. It announced a criminal investigation into the incident

This is who Macklemore's protest song Hind's Hall is about. She is one of the thousands of Palestinian children billionaire Robert Kraft is trying to erase from history.

Ed Sheeran also appeared to shield himself behind the idea that he has a younger fanbase and that audiences come to his concerts to escape politics.

Yet one of the most prominent voices speaking about Palestinian children over the past year has been Ms Rachel, whose audience consists largely of toddlers and young children.

The idea that having young fans automatically disqualifies someone from speaking about humanitarian issues simply does not stand up to scrutiny.

Children are often the very reason people speak out in the first place. What about the thousands of other children like Hind? Do they not matter to Ed Sheeran?

The question is not whether Macklemore will survive losing several tour dates. He will.

The question is whether Palestinian children can be spoken about on one of the world’s biggest stages without the person speaking being removed.

Ed Sheeran said he wanted to “maintain diplomacy and keep conversation open”.

He then switched off the comments beneath his Instagram statement.

Nothing says maintaining diplomacy and keeping the conversation open quite like turning the conversation off.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos