I have watched the footage of Henry Nowak’s final interaction with police several times, and each time I am left with the same feeling: disbelief.
Not because policing is easy. It isn’t. Not because officers always have perfect information. They don’t.
But because what I saw appeared to be a seriously injured young man repeatedly saying he had been stabbed, repeatedly saying he could not breathe, and yet the urgency I would have expected seemed absent.
The Independent Office for Police Conduct investigation must now establish exactly what happened, and it is important that process is allowed to run its course.
However, there are questions that many of us are already asking.
At the heart of our justice system sits a simple principle: innocent until proven guilty.
It is one of the cornerstones of a fair and democratic society. Yet what many people believe they witnessed was a young man’s injuries becoming secondary to the assumptions being made about him.
That should concern all of us.
Whether someone is a victim, a witness or a suspect, they do not stop being human. They do not lose their right to dignity. They do not lose their right to compassion. And they certainly do not lose their right to medical attention when they are injured and asking for help.
That is why this case has struck such a chord with so many people.
What troubled me most was not simply what happened, but what it appeared to represent.
A mindset. A mindset where assumptions can take hold before all the facts are known. A mindset where suspicion risks outweighing humanity. A mindset where a person in obvious distress is not afforded the urgency their condition demands.
If that is what happened here, it should prompt serious reflection.
Many people have drawn comparisons with George Floyd because they recognise a familiar and deeply uncomfortable pattern. A person in distress repeatedly telling those in authority that something is wrong, while those warnings appear not to receive the urgency they deserve.
The question many are asking is why.
Was it because assumptions had already been made? Was it because one version of events had already been accepted? Was it because a narrative had formed before the full facts were understood?
These are difficult questions, but they are questions that deserve answers.
I understand that police officers often arrive at scenes with limited information. They are expected to make quick decisions in situations most of us will never experience. The vast majority carry out that responsibility professionally and with integrity.
But professionalism is not simply about enforcing the law.
It is about judgement. It is about recognising vulnerability. It is about preserving life. And it is about never losing sight of the human being in front of you.
Public trust is not built on the belief that mistakes never happen. Public trust is built on accountability, transparency and a willingness to learn when things go wrong.
Without accountability, trust begins to erode. Without trust, confidence in policing suffers.
And without humanity, the relationship between the public and those entrusted to protect them becomes increasingly fragile.
As someone who spends much of my time working with communities and public institutions, I know how difficult trust can be to build and how quickly it can be lost.
That is why this matters.
Not only for Henry’s family, who deserve answers, but for every community that wants to believe that when they are vulnerable, when they are frightened, or when they are injured, they will be treated with fairness, care and compassion.
The role of the police is not simply to investigate crime. It is to protect life. Everything else should come after that. The footage has left many people asking whether that principle was forgotten.
I do not know what the investigation will conclude.
What I do know is that a young man lost his life, a family is grieving, and a great many people have been left asking a simple but profoundly important question:
If a young man is bleeding, saying he has been stabbed, and telling those around him that he cannot breathe, why wasn’t that enough?
Because every person, regardless of who they are or what they are accused of, deserves to be treated with dignity, compassion and humanity.
That should never be up for debate.
Share