Criticism of candidates's English skills 'disrespectful'

Election candidate Shabbir Dudhara speaking in the video <i>(Image: B Buzz Media)</i>
Election candidate Shabbir Dudhara speaking in the video (Image: B Buzz Media)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A Blackburn election candidate who was ridiculed for speaking Gujarati in a campaign video said he is ‘disappointed’ with the personal attack on him.

Shabbir Dudhara, who is standing in the Billinge and Beardwood ward, was filmed alongside Labour councillors. Whilst the other three Labour councillors spoke in English, Mr Dudhara chose to speak in Gujarati, thanking the councillors for their support.

It prompted a post on the 4 BwD Independents Facebook page, which poured scorn on his language skills.

The video and words were also shared on WhatsApp.

The criticism appeared to be all the more bizarre as it was other South Asians and those of Indian descent, in particular, who were calling out his lack of English skills.

The post said: “This situation makes a mockery of democratic representation. While all other participants spoke in English, the candidate spoke only in Gujarati.

“It is disrespectful to constituents for the Labour Party to select a candidate unable to communicate in English, especially when senior serving councillors are endorsing this candidate. We must uphold proper standards - this is not Bharuch Bazaar.”

The post on Facebook was deleted by Monday after people called the references ‘prejudicial’ against Gujaratis and also failed to take into account how historically South Asians have had to face such comments from 'racist' elements in society.

The post saw a flurry of criticism from the Bharuchi Gujaratis community, who called for an apology.

Many first-generation Gujaratis in Lancashire hail from Bharuch, whilst others from the area of Surat in India and parts of the African continent.

A senior 4 BwD Group councillor did, however, speak out this week.

He said being fluent in English ‘should not be a barrier to standing’ but ‘communicating effectively with residents and officers’ was important for any candidate.

Shabbir Dudhara said he had been a taxi driver for over a decade, so obviously had a grasp of English.

He said: “I am disappointed. They have no right to say this.

“This is the first time I am standing, and I expected better.

“I have had a lot of people call, and they are upset.”

In other campaign videos shared by the candidate himself on social media, he can be heard speaking in both Gujarati and English.

Cllr Jackie Floyd, who represents Billinge and Beardwood, said she had accompanied Mr Dudhara on the campaign trail.

“I found the criticism of his language skills very disappointing. I found it very sad that this should happen, and I do think people need to realise the consequences of their actions," she said.

“We represent people from all walks of life and all parts of the world and cultures. This is what makes all our communities great.

“I have to say the comment was derogatory, and it upset me, so I knew it would upset many others, too.

“I only speak English, whilst other people have a different grasp of several languages.

“I realise that people are at different stages of their lives and will be picking up new skills as they go along.”

Cllr Floyd added: “It is not easy standing for election, and I have been happy to mentor and support Shabbir as we have visited people.”

Cllr Mustafa Desai from 4 BwD said he recognised that for some people English may be a second language.

He said: “There should absolutely be no prejudice whatsoever towards any candidate. The same standard applies to all parties and Independents.

“If elected, councillors must be able to carry out the role professionally — that means communicating effectively with residents and officers, and having the time and commitment the job demands.

“We’ve seen councillors in the past who haven’t fulfilled those responsibilities, and residents deserve better.

“However, having said that, it has also to be recognised that for some people English may be a second language.

“There are mechanisms and support available to help individuals in that position, and that should not be a barrier to standing. What matters is that all candidates are capable, committed, and will take the role seriously.”

Leader of the council Phil Riley, who appears in the video, said: “We have always recognised that people in the town may speak more than one language.

“We are perfectly fine with that.

“We have always represented and respected people from all cultures and backgrounds

“The criticism of Shabbir was, of course, disappointing, and I do not think anyone should be playing this card as a political leverage.”

A statement shared this week said the term ‘Bharuch Bazaar’ was ‘racist and offensive’ and ‘undermines the great contributions and legacy of the Bharuchi community’.

It read: “Public figures, especially elected representatives, should choose their words carefully and promote respect, unity, and dignity among all communities.”

All the candidates standing in the Billinge and Beardwood ward in May are: Imtiaz Ali – Conservative Party Candidate, Aimee Louise Dewse – Green Party, Shabbir Dudhara – Labour Party Candidate, Tasleem Fazal – Independent and Danny Wilson – Reform UK.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos