Insight

When human rights become negotiable, none of us are safe

When human rights become negotiable, none of us are safe <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
When human rights become negotiable, none of us are safe (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

When I read the report this week about the Prime Minister warning the European Court of Human Rights against “constraining democracies”, I felt a familiar chill.

The language being used ideas about “hierarchies of people” and the suggestion that some rights may need to be “reframed” should trouble all of us. These are not abstract legal tweaks.

They signal a shift away from the very principles that protect every person in this country, no matter their background, status or postcode.

What makes this moment so worrying is that it comes at a time when many communities already face disproportionate discrimination and vulnerability.

If we begin to dilute the universality of human rights even subtly, we risk deepening divides that are already painfully visible across society.

The article describes a political environment where rights are increasingly presented as obstacles.

Migrants are singled out as the group whose rights might be “balanced differently”, yet we know from decades of history that once you weaken protections for one group, the whole framework becomes less secure for everyone. It starts with those who have the least power, and it never ends there.

Evidence already shows the scale of inequality in the UK. The Equality and Human Rights Commission’s most recent monitoring report found persistent gaps in employment, health outcomes and policing for people from Black, Asian and other ethnic minority backgrounds.

Disabled people face discrimination in almost every part of public life. Hate crime, particularly racially and religiously motivated cases, remains high.

These are not small issues. They are warnings of what happens when systems stop treating people equally.

And at the same time, our public narrative is getting harsher. Research into parliamentary debates shows a marked shift towards securitised narratives on migration, framing non-citizens consistently through the lens of border control and illegality. When politicians and institutions repeatedly use that framing, it shapes how the public sees not just migrants, but anyone perceived as other.

It is not a coincidence that we have seen rises in Islamophobia, antisemitism and anti-Black racism alongside political rhetoric that positions certain groups as threats.

Now layer onto this a government signalling that some rights may need reviewing. It is not hard to imagine who could be most affected.

Those seeking Asylum, refugees, undocumented people, those in detention, women experiencing violence, racialised communities, LGBTQ plus people and individuals living with disability. Many already struggle to access justice and are often dismissed or disbelieved when they seek protection.

This is why I find the current conversation so dangerous. Human rights must not become political bargaining chips.

The Convention was created after the darkest chapter of European history precisely to prevent governments from deciding whose humanity is negotiable. As soon as we accept the idea of “hierarchies of people”, we walk away from that lesson.

So, what needs to be done.

First, leaders must stop using language that pits communities against each other. If the Prime Minister believes in the ECHR, as he claims, then his government should reaffirm its commitment to universal rights without caveats.

Second, any proposed changes to the interpretation of rights must come with a full equality impact assessment. Publish the data. Show which groups will be affected. And let independent bodies scrutinise it properly.

Third, we need to invest in strengthening rights, not trimming them back. That includes ensuring migrants can access safe legal support, improving equality training across the justice system and tackling the root causes of discrimination that so many reports have highlighted.

Above all, we have to remember that human rights are only meaningful when they apply to everyone. The moment a government starts carving out exceptions, the protections we take for granted become fragile.

Times like this call for clarity, honesty and courage. Because once universality is weakened, getting it back is far harder. And those who will feel it first are the very people already standing on the margins.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos