THE BBC’s coverage of Israel’s genocide in Gaza is “frankly despicable”. The person I’m quoting here is a BBC journalist, one of 13 whistleblowers who spoke to me as part of a newly published investigation for US outlet Drop Site News.
BBC staff are in revolt – more than 100 accused the corporation of pro-Israel bias last month –and their case is straightforward. The BBC is failing in its stated commitment to due impartiality. It offers excessive credulity about Israeli claims, devalues Palestinian life, ignores or whitewashes atrocities, and creates false equivalences.
The perennial desire to start the clock on October 7 was summed up by a reported comment by Deborah Turness, CEO of BBC News. In a rowdy editorial meeting in November 2023, two BBC journalists state she said: “We’ve got to all remember that this all started on October 7.” Liliane Landor, the former head of the BBC World Service, in reference to decades of Israeli occupation then calmly responded: “No, I’m going to have to say that’s not the case, and I’m sure that’s not how you meant to phrase it.”
READ MORE: Ireland takes eight Palestinian children with urgent health needs
Some examples of BBC reporting have been so egregious that public and internal outrage has forced corrections.
One example was in July this year, when the BBC reported the killing of a 24-year-old Palestinian with Down’s Syndrome, Muhammed Bhar, after he was attacked by an Israeli army dog, locked in a room, and his family forced from their home, before they returned to his decomposing body.
The BBC’s original headline was "The lonely death of Gaza man with Down’s syndrome", as though it was a natural death, while you had to read through 500 words to discover what had even happened.
The scale of backlash meant the BBC were forced to change the headline to "Gaza man with Down’s syndrome attacked by IDF dog and left to die, mother tells BBC". But this is what led BBC journalists to contact me: One said: “There has to be a moral line drawn in the sand. And if this story isn’t it, then what?”
As two brilliant data journalists, Dana Najjar and Jan Lietava, uncovered in a deep dive, there was far more proportionate coverage per Israeli death than Palestinian death.
There was only one major spike in the mention of Palestinian deaths – in early April – and the reasons are chilling. Israel bombed a World Central Kitchen aid convoy, killing several Westerners, but also their Palestinian driver, Saifeddin Issam Ayad Abutaha. Because Western deaths were involved, the BBC devoted extensive coverage, and thus the repeated mention of the nationalities of each victim – including Abutaha – drove up the mention of Palestinian deaths.
It took Western blood being spilt, in other words, for Palestinian life to really matter.
Their research exposed many other findings. Humanizing language like "daughter" or "grandfather" were proportionately used far more for Israeli deaths than Palestinian deaths, as were emotive terms like “massacre” or “atrocities”.
Staff had many examples. Reporting about Israeli crimes were framed around non-credible Israeli denials, like the killing of a 16-year-old girl by Israeli soldiers, or the storming of hospitals. Crucial details about how Israel is deliberately starving Gaza are excluded from reporting. Official Israeli statements committing to war crimes are buried, or not reported altogether.
The journalists emphasised it was a systemic problem, but they also referred to the role of Raffi Berg, the online Middle East editor. One former BBC journalist claims his “entire job is to water down everything that’s too critical of Israel”.
The BBC tell me they “reject your attack on an individual member of staff”, that like all staff he must “adhere to the BBC’s editorial guidelines”, and that I “fundamentally” misdescribe his role and misunderstand how the BBC works.
READ MORE: British involvement in Gaza 'much deeper than media acknowledge'
BBC staff passionately reject this. They note articles he has written, such as about the IDF and Israeli settlers, which they emphasise fail at basic impartiality. They note he attended a pro-Israel rally in 2009, and was even interviewed by the BBC in that capacity.
He wrote a book about Mossad and its evacuation of Jewish Ethiopians, in which he described the Israeli secret services in glowing terms and described a senior Mossad commander as a “legend” who became a “very close friend”.
He lauded Israeli officials, such as former Israeli ambassador Mark Regev, attending his book launch as a “big honour”, and repeatedly celebrated his book having pride of place on Benjamin Netanyahu’s bookshelf.
BBC staff claim he reshapes headlines, story text and even images in ways which foreground Israeli perspectives at the expense of Palestinians, with one calling his approach “death by a thousand cuts".
When I approached Berg with questions, he originally instructed defamation lawyer Mark Lewis, who is also the former director of UK Lawyers for Israel. The key point, really, is this: Would someone who attended pro-Palestinian rallies and celebrated associations with Palestinian figures be in his position?
BBC staff have fought to make changes, but their objections have been treated as emotional issues, or to do with some of them being Muslim.
But here’s the truth. This is one of the worst crimes of our age. Most media outlets failed to report accurately on what this is – The National being a striking exception.
It’s up to other journalists to speak up like these BBC staff members – or be forever complicit.
Share